Data Science

How do I choose between a Data Lake and a Data Warehouse for an enterprise Big Data architecture?

RE Asked by Rebecca Miller · 14-05-2024
0 upvotes 14,228 views 0 comments
The question

Our organization is struggling with massive amounts of unstructured data from IoT sensors and social media. We currently use a traditional SQL warehouse, but it’s becoming too expensive and slow to scale. Should we be looking at a Data Lake approach with Hadoop or S3, or is a "Lakehouse" architecture the modern standard for 2025? I need to understand the trade-offs regarding data governance and query speed for our analytics team.

 

3 answers

0
L
Answered on 16-05-2024

Rebecca, the decision hinges on the "schema-on-read" versus "schema-on-write" requirement. Data Warehouses are great for structured data and fast SQL queries, but they fail at scale with unstructured logs. A Data Lake allows you to store everything in its raw format cheaply. However, the modern "Lakehouse" architecture—using technologies like Databricks or Snowflake—is the sweet spot. It provides the low-cost storage of a lake with the management and ACID transactions of a warehouse. For IoT data specifically, the Lakehouse model prevents your storage from turning into a "Data Swamp" where nothing is searchable. 

0
S
Answered on 18-05-2024

Are you more concerned about the initial storage costs of the raw data, or the eventual latency your data scientists will face when running complex ML models? 

MA 19-05-2024

Steven, we are actually worried about both. Our current latency is killing our real-time reporting. We've started looking into Apache Iceberg to sit on top of our S3 buckets. It seems to provide that structure we need without the high cost of a proprietary warehouse. By addressing the "Metadata Gap," we’re hoping to keep our storage costs flat while giving the analysts a SQL-like experience that doesn't time out. It’s a tough balance to strike with 50TB of new data weekly.

0
NA
Answered on 20-05-2024

Go with the Lakehouse. It’s the standard now because it supports both BI reporting and Data Science workloads on the same data footprint, reducing duplication. 

RE 21-05-2024

I agree with Nancy. Eliminating the ETL overhead between the lake and the warehouse is the single biggest productivity boost a data team can achieve in 2025.

Share your thoughts

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked (*)

Professional Counselling Session

Still have questions?
Schedule a free counselling session

Our experts are ready to help you with any questions about courses, admissions, or career paths. Get personalized guidance from industry professionals.

Request a Call Back

Search Online

We Accept

We Accept

Follow Us

"PMI®", "PMBOK®", "PMP®", "CAPM®" and "PMI-ACP®" are registered marks of the Project Management Institute, Inc. | "CSM", "CST" are Registered Trade Marks of The Scrum Alliance, USA. | COBIT® is a trademark of ISACA® registered in the United States and other countries.

Book Free Session